Recently, I wrote about Using Storytelling Games in Software Testing, and pointed you to a paper by Martin Jansson and Greger Nolmark. Now I want to give you some tips on creating great storytelling for your testing projects.
First of all, check out Cem Kaner’s work on Scenario Testing: An Introduction to Scenario Testing. I want you to pay special attention to the CHAT (cultural, historical activity theory) model that he talks about. For more on CHAT and testing, read this paper: Putting the Context in Context-Driven Testing (an
Application of Cultural Historical Activity Theory).Pay special attention to the descriptions of networks of activity, and tensions. These are vital to help construct variations and different forces within our storytelling. Both of these pieces are foundational and worth the effort to dig into.
Now, I want you to read Hans Buwalda’s article on Soap Opera Testing. This is a nice variation on scenario testing. Buwalda uses television soap operas as inspiration for a story arcs, for structure, and for variation. Remember, there are lots of variations on a theme in testing, as well as real life! Further to that, look into testing tours. Cem Kaner has a blog post with a link or two to help get some background info: Testing tours: Research for Best Practices?.
Soap Opera tests, Testing Tours and Test Scenarios are a great place to start creating good testing stories.
Next, read up on personas in user experience work. Jenny Cham has a really nice description, with lots of helpful links on creating personas here: Creating design personas. Remember to explore her links in this blog, she has great advice here. I wrote a position paper about using UX personas in testing years ago (I will have to dig it up, there’s a dead link) in this blog post. Elisabeth Hendrickson introduced me to this idea, but she recommended using extreme personas such as cartoon characters. I prefer the standard UX methods pioneered by people like Alan Cooper, but the cartoon or other characters are a great place to start, especially if you feel stuck. Personas are a great way to start developing characters for your story that are relevant. What are their motivations when they use our software? What are their fears? What are their cares and worries and distractions?
Next, I want you to read this piece on telling a great story by a famous author: Kurt Vonnegut at the Blackboard. (I am getting to the gamification side of this project, and I asked Andrzej Marczewski for good references on storytelling in games, and this was the first link he sent me. Thanks Andrzej!) Notice the different options for structuring a good story. In testing, we can use different ones for the same scenario, if we think about activity patterns, tensions, characters, and variations during real life product use. Several versions of one story will yield different kinds of important information and observations. Vonnegut provides a simple framework for story creation that we can easily adapt and apply.
Finally, I want you to look at story telling in games. Andrzej talks about it here: I want to experience games not just play them. Notice that within a game context, of a well designed game, he has a sense of cause and effect: decisions made here can impact things in other areas of the game. That’s just like real life, and it is important to add dimensions to storytelling in games for testing. Variation and dimensions have different effects in a system, and they are rewarding to exercise. Now read this piece on Gamasutra The Designer’s Notebook: Three Problems for Interactive Storytellers, Resolved by Ernest Adams. The points about character amnesia, internal consistency and narrative flow are pure gold for testers. We often arrive into a system without really knowing what is going on, especially at first. However, our customers are also starting from scratch when they use our app for the first time. These problems are areas we should also address when creating stories to test around.
There is also a lot of really useful information here: Environmental Storytelling: Creating Immersive 3D Worlds Using Lessons Learned from the Theme Park Industry by Don Carson, particularly with regards to environmental conditions being so important to incorporate (particularly for you mobile testers!) and the idea of an all-encompassing world, rather than one, linear story.
As testers, we can incorporate more than a linear scenario into our work. We can add so much more depth to our test approach using stories and worlds. Story development in games is incredibly similar to the story telling we need to do in testing. There is a lot to be learned about creating virtual worlds and stories within them to help change our perspective, explore variations and make important discoveries about the software and systems we test. We can leverage these various works that have been provided with us to create something new and powerful.
Some final points to put this all together:
- Combine the elements from each of the areas I asked you to study above to create a great story, or even better, sets of stories
- Use structure to create real life conditions: different people, motivations, different environmental conditions, and change.
- Add plot twists, surprises and ulterior motives, and look for unintended consequences in systems and people
- Don’t stop at one scenario – create variations on a theme, and change the setting, or the entire world you have created to help change your perspective
- Introduce different characters – are they interrupting? Helping?
- Create a beginning, middle and an end
- Move beyond all happy endings – also try to leave things unresolved, or end on a bad note
I have compiled several foundational concepts to help influence your storytelling, so now the rest is up to you. How you combine them to create something useful is up to you and your team. You have an opportunity to create rich perspectives to kickstart your testing efforts.